these-ammii/thesis
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages 1 Wiki Activity Actions

small refactor
Some checks failed
/ test_checkout (push) Failing after 20s
Details

Browse source
This commit is contained in:
Jean-Marie 'Histausse' Mineau 2025-06-26 17:38:02 +02:00
parent e7a46aa2a9
commit 1ee8013522
Signed by: histausse
GPG key ID: B66AEEDA9B645AD2
50 changed files with 75 additions and 136 deletions
Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

4
4_rasta/data/average_mem-final.csv Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
first,type,adagio,amandroid,anadroid,androguard,androguarddad,apparecium,blueseal,dialdroid,didfail,droidsafe,flowdroid,gator,ic,icfork,iccta,mallodroid,perfchecker,redexer,saaf,wognsenetal
FINISHED,memory,0.6,4.5,12.8,0.6,0.3,1.3,2.7,15.9,17.6,9.9,2,2,15.3,5,5,0,0,1,3,3
FAILED,,0.3,4.9,2.8,0.4,1,0.6,1.7,3.9,68.3,14.8,5,41.5,130.9,5,12,0,1,1,1,1
TIMEOUT,,0,19,82.6,0,68.1,2.1,15.4,37.2,99.8,0.2,20.2,1.1,81.1,20,2,0,1,0,9,0
1 first type adagio amandroid anadroid androguard androguarddad apparecium blueseal dialdroid didfail droidsafe flowdroid gator ic icfork iccta mallodroid perfchecker redexer saaf wognsenetal
2 FINISHED memory 0.6 4.5 12.8 0.6 0.3 1.3 2.7 15.9 17.6 9.9 2 2 15.3 5 5 0 0 1 3 3
3 FAILED 0.3 4.9 2.8 0.4 1 0.6 1.7 3.9 68.3 14.8 5 41.5 130.9 5 12 0 1 1 1 1
4 TIMEOUT 0 19 82.6 0 68.1 2.1 15.4 37.2 99.8 0.2 20.2 1.1 81.1 20 2 0 1 0 9 0

7
4_rasta/data/average_number_of_error_by_exec.csv Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
first,type,adagio,amandroid,anadroid,androguard,androguarddad,apparecium,blueseal,dialdroid,didfail,droidsafe,flowdroid,gator,ic,icfork,iccta,mallodroid,perfchecker,redexer,saaf,wognsenetal
FINISHED,errors,0.0,0.9,0.02,0.0,0.0,3.33,0.0,55.88,1.13,7.17,1.04,0.0,1.22,0.32,14.3,4.37,0.28,1.29,0.22,2.13
,sigma,0.0,3.23,0.19,0.0,0.0,261.92,0.05,63.73,3.94,37.87,26.32,0.04,23.1,2.73,71.74,277.0,1.77,1.28,0.83,66.5
FAILED,errors,0.0,2.79,2.34,1.35,1.0,21.63,1.02,33.79,6.6,12.53,14.64,0.32,3.66,1.29,17.34,1.0,1.15,3.45,6.35,4.11
,sigma,0.0,8.7,0.94,0.48,0.02,466.97,0.21,108.56,31.56,74.01,49.07,0.78,18.06,0.71,42.81,0.0,4.7,4.52,22.97,48.81
TIMEOUT,errors,0,9.78,0.01,0,0.0,4.3,0.01,60.94,1.06,26.64,0.75,0.0,2.13,0.91,3.68,0,1.24,0,91.29,1.31
,sigma,0.0,9.76,0.11,0.0,0.0,79.98,0.11,101.73,2.98,97.18,1.72,0.0,5.19,3.19,15.33,0.0,4.3,0.0,353.75,3.42
1 first type adagio amandroid anadroid androguard androguarddad apparecium blueseal dialdroid didfail droidsafe flowdroid gator ic icfork iccta mallodroid perfchecker redexer saaf wognsenetal
2 FINISHED errors 0.0 0.9 0.02 0.0 0.0 3.33 0.0 55.88 1.13 7.17 1.04 0.0 1.22 0.32 14.3 4.37 0.28 1.29 0.22 2.13
3 sigma 0.0 3.23 0.19 0.0 0.0 261.92 0.05 63.73 3.94 37.87 26.32 0.04 23.1 2.73 71.74 277.0 1.77 1.28 0.83 66.5
4 FAILED errors 0.0 2.79 2.34 1.35 1.0 21.63 1.02 33.79 6.6 12.53 14.64 0.32 3.66 1.29 17.34 1.0 1.15 3.45 6.35 4.11
5 sigma 0.0 8.7 0.94 0.48 0.02 466.97 0.21 108.56 31.56 74.01 49.07 0.78 18.06 0.71 42.81 0.0 4.7 4.52 22.97 48.81
6 TIMEOUT errors 0 9.78 0.01 0 0.0 4.3 0.01 60.94 1.06 26.64 0.75 0.0 2.13 0.91 3.68 0 1.24 0 91.29 1.31
7 sigma 0.0 9.76 0.11 0.0 0.0 79.98 0.11 101.73 2.98 97.18 1.72 0.0 5.19 3.19 15.33 0.0 4.3 0.0 353.75 3.42

4
4_rasta/data/average_time-final.csv Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
first,type,adagio,amandroid,anadroid,androguard,androguarddad,apparecium,blueseal,dialdroid,didfail,droidsafe,flowdroid,gator,ic,icfork,iccta,mallodroid,perfchecker,redexer,saaf,wognsenetal
FINISHED,time,17.19,405.02,149.29,15.59,26.56,97.54,158.38,767.67,270.1,676.08,29.11,33.19,156.19,158.7,90.2,27.79,4.31,16.16,56.44,696.09
FAILED,,8.38,760.52,4.8,13.64,62.67,21.68,12.15,68.47,444.74,442.79,136.95,924.46,535.39,28.6,201.74,5.21,10.24,16.61,5.73,55.58
TIMEOUT,,0,3600.84,3600.83,0,3603.59,3600.23,3600.73,3604.0,3600.02,3600.08,3601.18,3600.56,3601.03,3600.92,3600.38,0,3600.04,0,3602.02,3600.55
1 first type adagio amandroid anadroid androguard androguarddad apparecium blueseal dialdroid didfail droidsafe flowdroid gator ic icfork iccta mallodroid perfchecker redexer saaf wognsenetal
2 FINISHED time 17.19 405.02 149.29 15.59 26.56 97.54 158.38 767.67 270.1 676.08 29.11 33.19 156.19 158.7 90.2 27.79 4.31 16.16 56.44 696.09
3 FAILED 8.38 760.52 4.8 13.64 62.67 21.68 12.15 68.47 444.74 442.79 136.95 924.46 535.39 28.6 201.74 5.21 10.24 16.61 5.73 55.58
4 TIMEOUT 0 3600.84 3600.83 0 3603.59 3600.23 3600.73 3604.0 3600.02 3600.08 3601.18 3600.56 3601.03 3600.92 3600.38 0 3600.04 0 3602.02 3600.55

27
4_rasta/data/data-final.csv Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
tool;citekey;binary;source;url;repo;documentation;decision;exclude;why;forkusable;authorconfirmed;lang;licences;os;origin;stars;alive;date;selected;selectedstars;selecteddate;nbaliveforks;remark;urlselected
A3E ;DBLPconfoopslaAzimN13;nr;ok;https://github.com/tanzirul/a3e;github;ok;ko;EXCLUDE;Hybrid tool (static/dynamic);ko;;;;;tanzirul/a3e;40;ko;2016-09-15;origin;40;2016-09-15;1;auto;https://github.com/tanzirul/a3e
A5 ;vidasA5AutomatedAnalysis2014;nr;ok;https://github.com/tvidas/a5;github;ko;ko;EXCLUDE;Hybrid tool (static/dynamic);ko;;;;;tvidas/a5;12;ko;2014-07-31;origin;12;2014-07-31;0;auto;https://github.com/tvidas/a5
Adagio ;gasconStructuralDetectionAndroid2013;nr;ok;https://github.com/hgascon/adagio;github;ok;ok;;;ko;ok;Python;GPL 2.0;U20.04;hgascon/adagio;74;ok;2022-11-17;origin;74;2022-11-17;0;auto;https://github.com/hgascon/adagio
Amandroid ;weiAmandroidPreciseGeneral2014;ok;ok;https://github.com/arguslab/Argus-SAF;github;ok;ok;;;ko;ok;Scala;Apache 2.0;U22.04;arguslab/Argus-SAF;161;ko;2021-11-10;origin;161;2021-11-10;2;auto;https://github.com/arguslab/Argus-SAF
Anadroid ;liangSoundPreciseMalware2013;ko;ok;https://github.com/maggieddie/pushdownoo;github;ok;ok;;;ko;ko;Scala/Java/Python;CRAPL 2012;U22.04;maggieddie/pushdownoo;10;ko;2014-06-18;origin;10;2014-06-18;0;auto;https://github.com/maggieddie/pushdownoo
Androguard ;desnos:adnroguard:2011;nr;ok;https://github.com/androguard/androguard;github;okk;ok;;;ko;ko;Python;Apache 2.0;Python 3.11 slim;androguard/androguard;4430;ok;2023-02-01;origin;4430;2023-02-01;3;auto;https://github.com/androguard/androguard
Android-app-analysis;geneiatakisPermissionVerificationApproach2015;ko;ok;https://code.google.com/archive/p/android-app-analysis-tool/source/default/source;google;okk;ko;EXCLUDE;Hybrid tool (static/dynamic);;;;;;android-app-analysis-tool;40;ko;2014-06-25;origin;;2014-06-25;;Android-app;https://code.google.com/archive/p/android-app-analysis-tool/source/default/source
Apparecium ;titzeAppareciumRevealingData2015;ok;ok;https://github.com/askk/apparecium;github;ko;ok;;;ko;ko;Python;MIT;U22.04;askk/apparecium;0;ko;2014-11-07;origin;0;2014-11-07;1;auto;https://github.com/askk/apparecium
BlueSeal ;shenInformationFlowsPermission2014;ko;ok;https://github.com/ub-rms/blueseal;github;bad;ok;;;ko;ok;Java;No licence;U14.04;ub-rms/blueseal;0;ko;2018-07-04;origin;0;2018-07-04;0;auto;https://github.com/ub-rms/blueseal
Choi #etal ;CHOI2014620;ko;ok;https://github.com/kwanghoon/javaAnalysis;github;bad;ko;EXCLUDE;Works on source files only;ko;;;;;kwanghoon/JavaAnalysis;1;ok;2022-01-09;origin;1;2022-01-09;0;auto;https://github.com/kwanghoon/JavaAnalysis
DIALDroid ;bosuCollusiveDataLeak2017;ok;ok;https://github.com/dialdroid-android/DIALDroid;github;ok;ok;;;ko;ko;Java;GPL 3.0;U18.04;dialdroid-android/DIALDroid;16;ko;2018-04-17;origin;16;2018-04-17;1;auto;https://github.com/dialdroid-android/DIALDroid
DidFail ;klieberAndroidTaintFlow2014;ok;ok;https://bitbucket.org/wklieber/didfail/src/master/;bitbucket;bad;ok;;;;ok;Java/Python;3-Clause BSD;U12.04;lori\_flynn/didfail;4;ko;2015-06-17;origin;;2015-06-17;;DidFail;https://bitbucket.org/wklieber/didfail/src/master/
DroidSafe ;DBLPconfndssGordonKPGNR15;ko;ok;https://github.com/MIT-PAC/droidsafe-src;github;ok;ok;;;ko;ok;Java/Python;GPL 2.0;U14.04;MIT-PAC/droidsafe-src;92;ko;2017-04-17;origin;92;2017-04-17;3;auto;https://github.com/MIT-PAC/droidsafe-src
Flowdroid ;Arzt2014a;ok;ok;https://github.com/secure-software-engineering/FlowDroid;github;okk;ok;;;ko;ok;Java;LGPL 2.1;U22.04;secure-software-engineering/FlowDroid;868;ok;2023-05-07;origin;868;2023-05-07;1;auto;https://github.com/secure-software-engineering/FlowDroid
Gator ;rountevStaticReferenceAnalysis2014,yangStaticControlFlowAnalysis2015;ko;ok;http://web.cse.ohio-state.edu/presto/software/gator/;edu;okk;ok;;;;ok;Java/Python;3-Clause BSD;U22.04;web;;;2019-09-09;origin;;2019-09-09;;Gator;http://web.cse.ohio-state.edu/presto/software/gator/
IC3 ;octeauCompositeConstantPropagation2015;ok;ok;https://github.com/siis/ic3;github;bad;ok;;;ok;ko;Java;Apache 2.0;U12.04 / 22.04;siis/ic3;32;ko;2015-09-17;JordanSamhi/ic3;4;2022-12-06;3;auto;https://github.com/JordanSamhi/ic3
IccTA ;liIccTADetectingInterComponent2015;ok;ok;https://github.com/lilicoding/soot-infoflow-android-iccta;github;ok;ok;;;ko;ok;Java;LGPL 2.1;U22.04;lilicoding/soot-infoflow-android-iccta;83;ko;2016-02-21;origin;83;2016-02-21;0;auto;https://github.com/lilicoding/soot-infoflow-android-iccta
Lotrack ;lillackTrackingLoadtimeConfiguration2014;ko;ok;https://github.com/MaxLillack/Lotrack;github;ko;bad;;Authors ack. a partial doc.;ko;ok;Java;Apache 2.0;?;MaxLillack/Lotrack;5;ko;2017-05-11;origin;5;2017-05-11;2;auto;https://github.com/MaxLillack/Lotrack
MalloDroid ;fahlWhyEveMallory2012;nr;ok;https://github.com/sfahl/mallodroid;github;ok;ok;;;ko;ko;Python;LGPL 3.0;U16.04;sfahl/mallodroid;64;ko;2013-12-30;origin;64;2013-12-30;10;auto;https://github.com/sfahl/mallodroid
PerfChecker ;liuCharacterizingDetectingPerformance2014;ko;ko;http://castle.cse.ust.hk/perfchecker/tool_obtain.php;request;bad;ok;;Binary obtained from authors;;ok;Java;Proprietary;U14.04;authors;;ko;--;origin;;--;;Perfchecker;???
Poeplau #etal;DBLPconfndssPoeplauFBKV14; ko ;bad;https://github.com/sebastianpoeplau/android-whitelists;github;ko;ko;EXCLUDE;Related to Android hardening;ko;;;;;sebastianpoeplau/android-whitelists;1;ko;2014-03-14;origin;1;2014-03-14;0;auto;https://github.com/sebastianpoeplau/android-whitelists
Redexer ;jeonDrAndroidMr2012;ko;ok;https://github.com/plum-umd/redexer;github;ok;ok;;;ko;ok;Ocaml/Ruby;3-Clause BSD;U22.04;plum-umd/redexer;153;ko;2021-05-20;origin;153;2021-05-20;0;auto;https://github.com/plum-umd/redexer
SAAF ;hoffmannSlicingDroidsProgram2013;ok;ok;https://github.com/SAAF-Developers/saaf;github;ok;ok;;;ko;ok;Java;GPL 3.0;U14.04;SAAF-Developers/saaf;35;ko;2015-09-01;origin;35;2015-09-01;5;auto;https://github.com/SAAF-Developers/saaf
StaDynA ;zhauniarovichStaDynAAddressingProblem2015; ko ;ok;https://github.com/zyrikby/StaDynA;request;ok;ko;EXCLUDE;Hybrid tool (static/dynamic);;;;;;authors;;;2020-02-14;origin;;2020-02-14;;Stadyna;https://github.com/zyrikby/StaDynA
Thresher ;blackshearThresherPreciseRefutations2013;ko;ok;https://github.com/cuplv/thresher;github;ok;bad;;Not built with author’s help;ko;ok;Java;Apache 2.0;U14.04;cuplv/thresher;31;ko;2014-10-25;origin;31;2014-10-25;1;auto;https://github.com/cuplv/thresher
Wognsen #etal;wognsenFormalisationAnalysisDalvik2014;nr;ok;https://bitbucket.org/erw/dalvik-bytecode-analysis-tool/src/master/;bitbucket;ko;ok;;;ko;ko;Python/Prolog;No licence;U22.04;erw/dalvik-bytecode-analysis-tool;;;2022-06-27;origin;;2022-06-27;;Wognsen;???
1 tool citekey binary source url repo documentation decision exclude why forkusable authorconfirmed lang licences os origin stars alive date selected selectedstars selecteddate nbaliveforks remark urlselected
2 A3E DBLPconfoopslaAzimN13 nr ok https://github.com/tanzirul/a3e github ok ko EXCLUDE Hybrid tool (static/dynamic) ko tanzirul/a3e 40 ko 2016-09-15 origin 40 2016-09-15 1 auto https://github.com/tanzirul/a3e
3 A5 vidasA5AutomatedAnalysis2014 nr ok https://github.com/tvidas/a5 github ko ko EXCLUDE Hybrid tool (static/dynamic) ko tvidas/a5 12 ko 2014-07-31 origin 12 2014-07-31 0 auto https://github.com/tvidas/a5
4 Adagio gasconStructuralDetectionAndroid2013 nr ok https://github.com/hgascon/adagio github ok ok ko ok Python GPL 2.0 U20.04 hgascon/adagio 74 ok 2022-11-17 origin 74 2022-11-17 0 auto https://github.com/hgascon/adagio
5 Amandroid weiAmandroidPreciseGeneral2014 ok ok https://github.com/arguslab/Argus-SAF github ok ok ko ok Scala Apache 2.0 U22.04 arguslab/Argus-SAF 161 ko 2021-11-10 origin 161 2021-11-10 2 auto https://github.com/arguslab/Argus-SAF
6 Anadroid liangSoundPreciseMalware2013 ko ok https://github.com/maggieddie/pushdownoo github ok ok ko ko Scala/Java/Python CRAPL 2012 U22.04 maggieddie/pushdownoo 10 ko 2014-06-18 origin 10 2014-06-18 0 auto https://github.com/maggieddie/pushdownoo
7 Androguard desnos:adnroguard:2011 nr ok https://github.com/androguard/androguard github okk ok ko ko Python Apache 2.0 Python 3.11 slim androguard/androguard 4430 ok 2023-02-01 origin 4430 2023-02-01 3 auto https://github.com/androguard/androguard
8 Android-app-analysis geneiatakisPermissionVerificationApproach2015 ko ok https://code.google.com/archive/p/android-app-analysis-tool/source/default/source google okk ko EXCLUDE Hybrid tool (static/dynamic) android-app-analysis-tool 40 ko 2014-06-25 origin 2014-06-25 Android-app https://code.google.com/archive/p/android-app-analysis-tool/source/default/source
9 Apparecium titzeAppareciumRevealingData2015 ok ok https://github.com/askk/apparecium github ko ok ko ko Python MIT U22.04 askk/apparecium 0 ko 2014-11-07 origin 0 2014-11-07 1 auto https://github.com/askk/apparecium
10 BlueSeal shenInformationFlowsPermission2014 ko ok https://github.com/ub-rms/blueseal github bad ok ko ok Java No licence U14.04 ub-rms/blueseal 0 ko 2018-07-04 origin 0 2018-07-04 0 auto https://github.com/ub-rms/blueseal
11 Choi #etal CHOI2014620 ko ok https://github.com/kwanghoon/javaAnalysis github bad ko EXCLUDE Works on source files only ko kwanghoon/JavaAnalysis 1 ok 2022-01-09 origin 1 2022-01-09 0 auto https://github.com/kwanghoon/JavaAnalysis
12 DIALDroid bosuCollusiveDataLeak2017 ok ok https://github.com/dialdroid-android/DIALDroid github ok ok ko ko Java GPL 3.0 U18.04 dialdroid-android/DIALDroid 16 ko 2018-04-17 origin 16 2018-04-17 1 auto https://github.com/dialdroid-android/DIALDroid
13 DidFail klieberAndroidTaintFlow2014 ok ok https://bitbucket.org/wklieber/didfail/src/master/ bitbucket bad ok ok Java/Python 3-Clause BSD U12.04 lori\_flynn/didfail 4 ko 2015-06-17 origin 2015-06-17 DidFail https://bitbucket.org/wklieber/didfail/src/master/
14 DroidSafe DBLPconfndssGordonKPGNR15 ko ok https://github.com/MIT-PAC/droidsafe-src github ok ok ko ok Java/Python GPL 2.0 U14.04 MIT-PAC/droidsafe-src 92 ko 2017-04-17 origin 92 2017-04-17 3 auto https://github.com/MIT-PAC/droidsafe-src
15 Flowdroid Arzt2014a ok ok https://github.com/secure-software-engineering/FlowDroid github okk ok ko ok Java LGPL 2.1 U22.04 secure-software-engineering/FlowDroid 868 ok 2023-05-07 origin 868 2023-05-07 1 auto https://github.com/secure-software-engineering/FlowDroid
16 Gator rountevStaticReferenceAnalysis2014,yangStaticControlFlowAnalysis2015 ko ok http://web.cse.ohio-state.edu/presto/software/gator/ edu okk ok ok Java/Python 3-Clause BSD U22.04 web 2019-09-09 origin 2019-09-09 Gator http://web.cse.ohio-state.edu/presto/software/gator/
17 IC3 octeauCompositeConstantPropagation2015 ok ok https://github.com/siis/ic3 github bad ok ok ko Java Apache 2.0 U12.04 / 22.04 siis/ic3 32 ko 2015-09-17 JordanSamhi/ic3 4 2022-12-06 3 auto https://github.com/JordanSamhi/ic3
18 IccTA liIccTADetectingInterComponent2015 ok ok https://github.com/lilicoding/soot-infoflow-android-iccta github ok ok ko ok Java LGPL 2.1 U22.04 lilicoding/soot-infoflow-android-iccta 83 ko 2016-02-21 origin 83 2016-02-21 0 auto https://github.com/lilicoding/soot-infoflow-android-iccta
19 Lotrack lillackTrackingLoadtimeConfiguration2014 ko ok https://github.com/MaxLillack/Lotrack github ko bad Authors ack. a partial doc. ko ok Java Apache 2.0 ? MaxLillack/Lotrack 5 ko 2017-05-11 origin 5 2017-05-11 2 auto https://github.com/MaxLillack/Lotrack
20 MalloDroid fahlWhyEveMallory2012 nr ok https://github.com/sfahl/mallodroid github ok ok ko ko Python LGPL 3.0 U16.04 sfahl/mallodroid 64 ko 2013-12-30 origin 64 2013-12-30 10 auto https://github.com/sfahl/mallodroid
21 PerfChecker liuCharacterizingDetectingPerformance2014 ko ko http://castle.cse.ust.hk/perfchecker/tool_obtain.php request bad ok Binary obtained from authors ok Java Proprietary U14.04 authors ko -- origin -- Perfchecker ???
22 Poeplau #etal DBLPconfndssPoeplauFBKV14 ko bad https://github.com/sebastianpoeplau/android-whitelists github ko ko EXCLUDE Related to Android hardening ko sebastianpoeplau/android-whitelists 1 ko 2014-03-14 origin 1 2014-03-14 0 auto https://github.com/sebastianpoeplau/android-whitelists
23 Redexer jeonDrAndroidMr2012 ko ok https://github.com/plum-umd/redexer github ok ok ko ok Ocaml/Ruby 3-Clause BSD U22.04 plum-umd/redexer 153 ko 2021-05-20 origin 153 2021-05-20 0 auto https://github.com/plum-umd/redexer
24 SAAF hoffmannSlicingDroidsProgram2013 ok ok https://github.com/SAAF-Developers/saaf github ok ok ko ok Java GPL 3.0 U14.04 SAAF-Developers/saaf 35 ko 2015-09-01 origin 35 2015-09-01 5 auto https://github.com/SAAF-Developers/saaf
25 StaDynA zhauniarovichStaDynAAddressingProblem2015 ko ok https://github.com/zyrikby/StaDynA request ok ko EXCLUDE Hybrid tool (static/dynamic) authors 2020-02-14 origin 2020-02-14 Stadyna https://github.com/zyrikby/StaDynA
26 Thresher blackshearThresherPreciseRefutations2013 ko ok https://github.com/cuplv/thresher github ok bad Not built with author’s help ko ok Java Apache 2.0 U14.04 cuplv/thresher 31 ko 2014-10-25 origin 31 2014-10-25 1 auto https://github.com/cuplv/thresher
27 Wognsen #etal wognsenFormalisationAnalysisDalvik2014 nr ok https://bitbucket.org/erw/dalvik-bytecode-analysis-tool/src/master/ bitbucket ko ok ko ko Python/Prolog No licence U22.04 erw/dalvik-bytecode-analysis-tool 2022-06-27 origin 2022-06-27 Wognsen ???